RE teacher suspended over Prophet Muhammad cartoon ‘defended his right to freedom of speech’

View
comments

The RE teacher suspended over a cartoon of the Prophet Muhammad is reported to have ‘defended his right to freedom of speech’ in a heated telephone call with the father of a Muslim pupil at Batley Grammar School, Mail Online can reveal.

The ‘burly Yorkshire lad’ in his 20s, who has not been named, is also disclosed as saying ‘British values allowed him to present a cartoon of the Prophet Muhammad to his class of year nine students as part of their course work’.

The suspended teacher, who allegedly showed a caricature widely reported as taken from the French satirical newspaper Charlie Hebdo, telephoned the irate father after he had called the school and left a message to speak with him.

A petition started by students of the RE teacher has also passed 35,000 signatures today after police whisked him away for his own safety. 

Police are providing support to the teacher after protestors gathered outside the school near Bradford, West Yorkshire, for a second day on Friday, with Headteacher Gary Kibble keeping 980 children at home.   

It follows Communities Secretary Robert Jenrick saying protests taking place outside the school were ‘not right’, adding that suggestions the teacher was in hiding are ‘very disturbing’.   

When the teacher returned the call he told the father that he had warned his pupils that some would find it offensive, but his aim was to pose a question to his class.

He believed he was ‘right’ to show the cartoon which has offended Muslims across the world.

He wanted to discuss whether the cartoonist was to blame or the terrorists who had committed murder over it in France after the satirical magazine Charlie Hebdo had published it. 

The angry father said the teacher was not apologetic when told that the showing the cartoon to his son was offensive and instead was ‘arrogant’ and asked the parents to voice his concerns to others at the school.

In a group Whatsapp message, shared among Islamic parents and protesters who have demonstrated outside the school and seen by Mail Online, the father said: ‘He should have known better.

‘I expressed I was not happy with his actions and he had caused offence to the community. He should have known better, after all these images caused international outrage.

‘He was not apologetic and was arrogant in his response that what he did was right. He stated that he knew some of the pupils would tell their parents.’

But the suspended teacher, who has apologised, has been forced to leave his home and into hiding with his family.  

Meanwhile, Mr Jenrick has said children should be taught ‘contentious issues appropriately’. 

He told the BBC: ‘It must be right that a teacher can appropriately show images of the Prophet Muhammad.

‘In a free society, we want religions to be taught to children and for children to be able to question and query them.’

He also told Sky News: ‘I was disturbed to see scenes of people protesting outside the school – that is not right.

‘We shouldn’t have teachers, members of staff of schools, feeling intimidated, and the reports that a teacher may even be in hiding is very disturbing.

‘That is not a road we want to go down in this country, so I would strongly urge people who are concerned about this issue not to do that.’

On Thursday, the school ‘unequivocally’ apologised for showing ‘totally inappropriate’ material to children, and said a member of staff was suspended pending an investigation.

A protester speaking ‘on behalf of the Muslim community’ read out a statement outside of the school on Friday, in which he said: ‘The teachers have breached the position of trust and failed their duty of safeguarding, and this issue must be addressed as a matter of urgency.

‘We do not accept that the school has taken this issue seriously, given that it’s taken them four days to merely suspend only one of the teachers involved.’

He called on the entire British Muslim community to review the materials being taught in their children’s schools.

One protester, whose children attend the school, and who only wanted to be identified as Mr Hussain, said: ‘What people are trying to convey here to the media, and to the British public at large, is we would not like any form of extremism, any extremist viewpoints, to be taught to children.’

He said the western world ‘is at a loss in understanding the reaction’ from the Muslim community when the Prophet Muhammad is ‘insulted in any way, shape or form’.

He said: ‘A Muslim is required to stand up when Prophet Muhammad is insulted, and when all the prophets are insulted, including all the prophets of the Old Testament, including Jesus.’

Labour MP for Batley and Spen, Tracey Brabin, condemned those who ‘seek to fan the flames of this incident’, and welcomed the school’s apology.

‘No teacher should be facing intimidation or threats, there is no excuse for that,’ she said. The focus must be on the welfare and education of the children at this school.’

Mr Jenrick said the Department for Education (DfE) is working with the school and local council as it investigates the incident.

‘What I can say is there has to be an appropriate balance – we have to ensure there is free speech, that teachers can teach uninhibited but that has to be done in a respectful and tolerant way and that’s a balance to be struck by teaching professionals and the schools concerned,’ Mr Jenrick said.

Baroness Warsi, former chairwoman of the Conservative party, said the incident has been ‘hijacked by extremists on both sides’ to create a culture war. 

Speaking to the Today programme, the peer said she had spoken to pupils and parents over the past 24 hours, and ‘it’s obvious that many pupils were left distressed because of what happened’.

She said: ‘What we’re forgetting in all of this is the most important party in all of this, which is the kids and their learning.’

Geoff Barton, general secretary of the Association of School and College Leaders, said the school should be allowed to investigate the matter ‘without a running commentary in the media, on social media, and outside the school gates’.

Baroness Kishwer Falkner, who chairs the Equality and Human Rights Commission, said: ‘Children’s education should not be disrupted by protests in what has already been a difficult year.

‘The school is taking action and ought to be trusted to do so. A teacher’s identity being shared, making them fear for their safety, is simply unacceptable and could result in enforcement action from the police.

‘Schools are places where children learn about ideas, values, difference and respect. This sometimes involves exposing them to contentious issues and different views and ideas. For schools to meet their legal duty to foster good relations between people from different groups, this should be done in a balanced, respectful and sensitive way.’

The DfE came under fire for amplifying divisions after it branded the protests ‘completely unacceptable’, and said they included ‘threats’ and ‘intimidation’.

Muhammad Shafiq, chief executive of Manchester-based Ramadhan Foundation, said: ‘It is alarming that the Department for Education chose to amplify those divisions by attacking the parents and pupils rather than looking how we can come together to have a respectful discussion and seek an end to this issue.’